Current:Home > MyFederal judge puts Idaho’s ‘abortion trafficking’ law on hold during lawsuit-DB Wealth Institute B2 Reviews & Ratings
Federal judge puts Idaho’s ‘abortion trafficking’ law on hold during lawsuit
lotradecoin securities View Date:2024-12-26 05:27:51
BOISE, Idaho (AP) — A federal judge has temporarily blocked Idaho’s “abortion trafficking” law from being enforced while a lawsuit challenging its constitutionality is underway.
“This lawsuit is not about the right to an abortion. It is about much more,” U.S. District Magistrate Debora K. Grasham wrote in the ruling handed down Wednesday. “Namely, long-standing and well recognized fundamental rights of freedom of speech, expression, due process, and parental rights. These are not competing rights, nor are they at odds.”
Abortion is banned in Idaho at all stages of pregnancy, and the law enacted in May was designed to prevent minors from getting abortions in states where the procedure is legal if they don’t have their parents’ permission. Under the law, people who help a minor who isn’t their own child arrange an abortion out of state can be charged with a felony, though they can then attempt to defend themselves in court later by proving that the minor had parental permission for the trip.
Supporters of the law call it an “abortion trafficking” ban. Opponents say it is an unconstitutional prohibition on interstate travel and free speech rights.
Two advocacy groups and an attorney who works with sexual assault victims sued the state and Idaho Attorney General Raul Labrador over the law earlier this year. Nampa attorney Lourdes Matsumoto, the Northwest Abortion Access Fund, and the Indigenous Idaho Alliance all work with and sometimes assist minors who are seeking abortions, and they wrote in the lawsuit that they wanted to continue without the threat of prosecution.
They said the law is so vague that they can’t tell what conduct would or would not be legal, and that it violates the First Amendment right of free expression. They also argued that the law infringes on the Fourth Amendment right to travel between states, as well as the right to travel within Idaho.
Grasham agreed with the state’s attorneys that there is no court-protected right of travel within the state under existing case law in Idaho, and she dismissed that part of the lawsuit. But she said the other three claims could move forward, noting that the plaintiffs’ intended assistance to minors is essentially an expression of their core beliefs, in the form of messages of “support and solidarity for individuals seeking legal reproductive options.”
The judge wrote that she wasn’t placing free expression or due process above parental rights or vice versa, saying those rights have co-existed in harmony for decades and can continue to do so.
“The state can, and Idaho does, criminalize certain conduct occurring within its own borders such as abortion, kidnapping, and human trafficking. What the state cannot do is craft a statute muzzling the speech and expressive activities of a particular viewpoint with which the state disagrees under the guise of parental rights,” she wrote.
Prosecutors in eastern Idaho recently charged a woman and her son with second-degree kidnapping, alleging they took the son’s minor girlfriend out of state to get an abortion. The prosecutors did not invoke the so-called “abortion trafficking” law in that case. Instead, they said the criminal kidnapping charge was brought because the mother and son intended to “keep or conceal” the girl from her parents by transporting “the child out of the state for the purpose of obtaining an abortion.”
The woman’s defense attorney did not immediately return a phone call. seeking comment The son’s court file was not available online, and it wasn’t immediately clear if the case against him was still underway.
veryGood! (33)
Related
- Usher Cancels Atlanta Concert Hours Before Show to Rest and Heal
- Stephen Amell was focused on 'NCIS' spinoff when he landed 'Suits' gig
- Micah Parsons left ankle injury: Here's the latest on Dallas Cowboys star defender
- Kylie Jenner's Pal Yris Palmer Shares What It’s Really Like Having a Playdate With Her Kids
- White House says deals struck to cut prices of popular Medicare drugs that cost $50 billion yearly
- Opinion: Antonio Pierce's cold 'business' approach reflects reality of Raiders' challenges
- Jana Kramer Reveals She Lost “Almost Half Her Money” to Mike Caussin in Divorce
- Friend says an ex-officer on trial in fatal beating of Tyre Nichols did his job ‘by the book’
- Emily in Paris' Ashley Park Reveals How Lily Collins Predicted Her Relationship With Costar Paul Forman
- Kendra Wilkinson Shares Rare Update on Her Kids Hank and Alijah
Ranking
- NASA still hasn't decided the best way to get the Starliner crew home: 'We've got time'
- 'Still floating': Florida boaters ride out Hurricane Helene
- The Chilling True Story Behind Into the Fire: Murder, Buried Secrets and a Mother's Hunch
- 5 people killed in a 4-vehicle chain reaction crash on central Utah highway
- Head of Theodore Roosevelt National Park departs North Dakota job
- A rare condor hatched and raised by foster parents in captivity will soon get to live wild
- Love is Blind's Marshall Glaze and Fiancée Chay Barnes Break Up Less Than One Year After Engagement
- Salvador Perez's inspiring Royals career gets MLB postseason return: 'Kids want to be like him'
Recommendation
-
Kaley Cuoco and Tom Pelphrey announce engagement with new photos
-
Ohio’s fall redistricting issue sparked a fight over one word. So what is ‘gerrymandering,’ anyway?
-
Alabama carries out the nation's second nitrogen gas execution
-
Federal government postpones sale of floating offshore wind leases along Oregon coast
-
How 'Millionaire' host Jimmy Kimmel helped Team Barinholtz win stunning top prize
-
Opinion: Antonio Pierce's cold 'business' approach reflects reality of Raiders' challenges
-
Wisconsin Supreme Court says Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s name will remain on swing state’s ballot
-
Wisconsin city’s mailing of duplicate absentee ballots raises confusion, questions over elections